23-year-old Nicholas Bell, a native of Manchester, wiped tears from his face as he answered to manslaughter charges stemming from the Thanksgiving Day shooting death of his close buddy. "It's an absolutely tragic day for everyone involved," said Bennington County State's Attorney Erica Marthage. "It certainly highlights the importance of gun safety."
Manchester Police say Bell and 24-year-old Jeffrey Charbonneau had spent the night at another friend's house. Bell called 911 for help, telling the dispatcher he tried to wake Charbonneau up Thursday morning using what he thought was a non-lethal pellet gun, but what was really a .22 caliber rifle aimed at Charbonneau's chest.
"It was just on the wall in his little brother's room," Bell said in 911 transcripts included in court records. "I thought it was an Air Soft gun or something, and the next thing I knew, it fired, I squeezed it and it fired. I didn't think it was loaded. I had no idea."
"We filled the courthouse because he's our dear friend," explained Victoria Kraft of Dorset.
Kraft was one of more than 3-dozen friends and relatives supporting both Bell and the man he's charged with fatally shooting. "We want [Nick Bell] to know he can honor Jeff for his whole life, just like we all will do," Kraft said.
Bell pled not guilty to the charges that could bring a 1-to-15 year prison sentence. Prosecutors say Charbonneau's death was an accident, but one that demands punishment. "It's difficult to imagine this would be considered an appropriate prank in any home in Vermont," Marthage said.
Police and prosecutors are not sure whether Bell was drunk at the time of the shooting, but he told investigators the men went out to a restaurant and bar the night before.
High school classmates of both Charbonneau and Bell call the apparent mixup a heartbreaking blow to their tight circle of friends. The group gathered in the courtroom remembers Charbonneau as an avid traveler, a UVM economics grad, and a high school hockey and soccer player. Members of the group said they'll miss Charbonneau dearly, but added Bell is no villain.
"We've just known him all of our lives, and just know what an awesome, wonderful individual he is," said Calley Schubert of Manchester. "And we're just here to show our support and our love and back him up in these really difficult times for everybody."
"I hope it's a very large lesson learned to our community at large as to what can happen when we're not careful," Kraft said.
Nick Bell's father posted $25,000 bail. Under the conditions of Bell's release, he'll have a curfew, is not to have contact with the Charbonneaus, and is not to handle any guns.
Wednesday, June 19 2013 11:54 PM EDT2013-06-20 03:54:35 GMT
Cornwall is the latest town saying no to a plan to bring natural gas to the International Paper Mill at Ticonderoga. "I will fight you tooth and nail, I don't want this for any of us on any level," saidMore >>
Cornwall is the latest town saying no to a plan to bring natural gas to the International Paper Mill at Ticonderoga.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 6:12 PM EDT2013-06-19 22:12:23 GMT
A big drug sweep in Springfield this morning targeted drug dealers.More >>
Dozens of alleged drug dealers are behind bars after police conducted a large drug sweep throughout Windsor County. WCAX's Jennifer Reading was with police and got exclusive access during Wednesday's roundup.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 4:36 PM EDT2013-06-19 20:36:22 GMT
Burlington police are investigating a hit-and-run accident. Police say Monday at 4:10 p.m., a woman was walking in the crosswalk at College St. near the Waterman Building at UVM, when she was hit by anMore >>
Police are asking the public for help identifying the suspect in a hit-and-run accident on College Street in Burlington.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 10:03 AM EDT2013-06-19 14:03:21 GMT
A former Customs Agent will sell more more than 150 guns that were seized from his Brattleboro home during a 2011 raid. Special Agent Richard Bernholz pleaded guilty Tuesday in federal court to filingMore >>
A former Customs Agent will sell more more than 150 guns that were seized from his Brattleboro home during a 2011 raid.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 6:54 PM EDT2013-06-19 22:54:38 GMT
A propane leak forced evacuations in St. Albans Wednesday. Investigators say someone was operating a hydraulic lift at a property on Lakeshore Drive when the top of an underground tank was clipped, causingMore >>
Several homes in St. Albans were evacuated Wednesday after an underground tank was damaged and started to leak.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 7:48 PM EDT2013-06-19 23:48:02 GMT
"At 0.05 you are already impaired. The danger of being on the road is real," said Rep. Bill Lippert, D-Hinesburg. State Representative Bill Lippert thinks the current standard to determine if someone isMore >>
A Vermont lawmaker wants to cut the legal limit for drunk driving nearly in half. Proponents say the proposal will save lives; opponents say it will kill business.More >>