Quantcast

Jury Selected in 1991 Murder Case - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

Jury Selected in 1991 Murder Case

Howard Godfrey Howard Godfrey
Dave & Ann Scoville Dave & Ann Scoville
Patricia Scoville Patricia Scoville

White River Junction, Vermont - January 10, 2008

Howard "Skip" Godfrey, 60, was delivered to court wearing a new suit, tie, shirt, haircut and glasses-- a much different appearance than he had when he was arrested three years ago. His arrest came fourteen years after Patty Scoville, 28, was raped and suffocated in a shallow grave in the hillside above Stowe's Moss Glen Falls.

Police had DNA evidence from the crime scene. Over the years, hundreds of comparisons with DNA profiles of potential suspects did not produce a match.

Her parents, Dave and Ann Scoville, provided testimony to Congress that led to the creation of a national FBI DNA database in hopes it would identify a suspect in their daughter's murder. It did. 14 years later, Godfrey's DNA profile for a 1996 attempted abduction of a woman in Johnson, matched the DNA from the Scoville murder.

Police say Godfrey initially denied ever knowing Patty Scoville. But after they told him about the DNA match he changed his story and claimed he had consensual sex with her but he didn't kill her.

At jury selection, his lawyers-- speaking out of range from microphones-- told the potential jurors, "this is not a question of whether or not Skip and Patricia Scoville had sex. They did. He told the police that." Godfrey's lawyers wanted to know if potential jurors would keep an open mind or hold it against Godfrey if he did not testify.

Prosecutors wanted to know if they would be willing to convict on the basis of circumstantial as well as direct scientific evidence.

After two days of jury selection a panel was selected: 12 women and 3 men-- three of them to be designated as alternates in case any of the twelve primaries have to be replaced. All of the lawyers declined comment as did Patty Scoville's parents. The lawyers will deliver opening statements to the jury Friday morning.

It appears Godfrey's lawyers will try to convince jurors that the prosecution cannot prove Godfrey was the killer.

Brian Joyce - WCAX News

Related Stories:

Incriminating Evidence Allowed in Murder Case

Arrest in Patricia Scoville Murder

Cold Case Cracked?

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Sen. Jim Jeffords to be laid to rest

    Sen. Jim Jeffords to be laid to rest

    Friday, August 22 2014 12:02 PM EDT2014-08-22 16:02:39 GMT
    Former U.S. Sen. Jim Jeffords will be laid to rest in Rutland today.
    Former U.S. Sen. Jim Jeffords will be laid to rest in Rutland today.
  • VSAC to keep federal student loans contract

    VSAC to keep federal student loans contract

    Friday, August 22 2014 1:41 PM EDT2014-08-22 17:41:37 GMT
    Vermont's congressional delegation says the Vermont Student Assistance Corporation will keep its federal contract to service student loans.
    Vermont's congressional delegation says the Vermont Student Assistance Corporation will keep its federal contract to service student loans.
  • Hearing on possible relocation of Elizabeth Teague

    Hearing on possible relocation of Elizabeth Teague

    Friday, August 22 2014 12:01 PM EDT2014-08-22 16:01:35 GMT
    A hearing is underway this afternoon regarding the possible relocation of accused workplace shooter Elizabeth Teague.
    A hearing is underway this afternoon regarding the possible relocation of accused workplace shooter Elizabeth Teague.
  • Vt. police say all clear in Newport

    Vt. police say all clear in Newport

    Friday, August 22 2014 11:12 AM EDT2014-08-22 15:12:45 GMT
    Police say the threat is over in Newport. Thursday night, police had asked residents to lock their doors and stay inside while authorities searched for a gunman.
    Police say the threat is over in Newport. Thursday night, police had asked residents to lock their doors and stay inside while authorities searched for a gunman.
  • Police: Couple wanted 2 Amish girls for slaves

    Police: Couple wanted 2 Amish girls for slaves

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:35 AM EDT2014-08-22 14:35:33 GMT
    An investigator says a northern New York couple kidnapped two Amish sisters from their family farm stand with a plan to turn them into slaves but released them after becoming frightened by news reports.
    An investigator says a northern New York couple kidnapped two Amish sisters from their family farm stand with a plan to turn them into slaves but released them after becoming frightened by news reports.
  • No bail for woman in Amish girls' kidnapping in NY

    No bail for woman in Amish girls' kidnapping in NY

    Friday, August 22 2014 1:49 PM EDT2014-08-22 17:49:29 GMT
    A woman accused along with her boyfriend of abducting and sexually abusing two young Amish sisters is due in court for a preliminary hearing.
    An investigator says a northern New York couple used a dog to lure two Amish sisters from their family farm stand with a plan to turn them into slaves.
  • Wire fraud convict has until Friday to object

    Wire fraud convict has until Friday to object

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:29 AM EDT2014-08-22 14:29:05 GMT
    A Vermont man convicted of wire fraud for submitting false invoices to a Maine town has reached the end of his allotted time to file objections to a pre-sentencing reporting.
    A Vermont man convicted of wire fraud for submitting false invoices to a Maine town has reached the end of his allotted time to file objections to a pre-sentencing reporting.
  • Parents had hoped to negotiate with Foley captors

    Parents had hoped to negotiate with Foley captors

    Friday, August 22 2014 12:41 PM EDT2014-08-22 16:41:27 GMT
    The parents of slain journalist James Foley say they regarded an email they received from his captors last week as a hopeful sign they could negotiate with Islamic militants.
    The parents of slain journalist James Foley say they regarded an email they received from his captors last week as a hopeful sign they could negotiate with Islamic militants.
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.