It may come down to a court battle between Vermont and the United States government. That's the general consensus among legal experts who have examined Senate bill 362. That bill that calls on Governor Jim Douglas to exert power over Vermont National Guard troops and bring them home from Iraq.
Authorization is the key issue in this bill, because the 1986 Montgomery Amendment says the president has control over National Guard troops if Congress has authorized the use of power. The 2002 Authorization for the Use of Military Force Against Iraq allows President Bush to use the Armed Forces to defend the country against the continuing threat posed by Iraq, and to enforce all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions regarding Iraq.
There are currently no U.N. Security Council resolutions that need implementation in Iraq, and backers of S.362 say the treat posed by Iraq is gone.
"Some could point to the President's statement several months after it began, quote, "mission accomplished" close quote, some would argue that that signals that the congressional authorization has expired," says Senator Vincent Illuzzi, R-Newport.
Illuzzi chairs the Senate Committee on Economic Development, Housing and General Affairs, which heard from legal experts on Tuesday regarding the bill.
Several experts say war appropriations may be the key in determining authorization.
"The question that's an interesting one is whether congress's actions, by continuing to adopt appropriations for the war, constitute a kind of implied authorization," says Peter Teachout, a constitutional law professor at Vermont Law School.
Most of the constitutional law experts who testified before Vermont lawmakers agree there is some legal ground for the bill to move forward, and that it would likely result in a court battle. Even so, some question whether it is a good idea.
"When states decide to play chicken with the federal military and the Pentagon in the middle of two shooting wars, that can be problematic," warns Michael Mello, also with the Vermont Law School.
Congress could potentially cut funding for the Guard, and Representative Michael Fisher says he's already heard comments that the bill is unpatriotic, but the backers of the bill say they are willing to risk that title if it means sparking a debate about the constitutional use of military forces.
Vermont is not alone in looking at this issue. Minnesota, Pennsylvania, and Rhode Island are considering similar legislation. Legal experts say at the very least, this type of bill could force Congress to clarify its authorization of force in Iraq.
Tuesday, December 10 2013 12:42 AM EST2013-12-10 05:42:52 GMT
A busy night Monday at the Burlington city council meeting where redistricting the city was a major discussion. Population shifts have forced the city to remap Burlington's districts to create more equalMore >>
A busy night Monday at the Burlington city council meeting where redistricting the city was a major discussion.More >>
Tuesday, December 10 2013 12:41 AM EST2013-12-10 05:41:52 GMT
Burlington considers plans for the run-down Moran Plant. For 25 years, the coal-fired power plant has stood empty on the Burlington waterfront. A proposed project -- called the "New Moran" -- would beMore >>
Burlington considers plans for the run-down Moran Plant.More >>
Tuesday, December 10 2013 12:41 AM EST2013-12-10 05:41:12 GMT
A child playing with a lighter was responsible for a Champlain, New York apartment fire. That's according to the Champlain Fire Department. Firefighters arrived at this apartment complex at 25 SpruceMore >>
A child playing with a lighter was responsible for a Champlain, New York apartment fire. That's according to the Champlain Fire Department.More >>
Tuesday, December 10 2013 12:39 AM EST2013-12-10 05:39:43 GMT
An equipment fire kept crews busy in Middlebury Monday. About 30 firefighters responded to a blaze at the Champlain Valley Equipment facility on Exchange Street. The Middlebury fire chief says there'sMore >>
An equipment fire kept crews busy in Middlebury Monday.More >>
Tuesday, December 10 2013 12:35 AM EST2013-12-10 05:35:13 GMT
Police say a woman walked out of the WalMart in Williston with two stolen computers Monday.The suspect was caught on surveillance cameras. The HP Pavilion computers are worth more than $1,000. If youMore >>
Police say a woman walked out of the Wal Mart in Williston with two stolen computers Monday.More >>
Monday, December 9 2013 10:26 PM EST2013-12-10 03:26:26 GMT
South Burlington is using a grant to tackle the slew of vacant properties near the airport.The city will use $17,000 for community outreach and research to make a plan for the homes. They were purchasedMore >>
South Burlington is using a grant to tackle the slew of vacant properties near the airport.More >>
Monday, December 9 2013 8:51 PM EST2013-12-10 01:51:48 GMT
When it comes to education, teachers say they know what it takes to motivate students, and also what doesn't work -- including standardized testing, cookie cutter curriculums and what NEA President MarthaMore >>
The Vermont NEA unveiled its "Agenda for Student Success" proposal Monday, and it points to a new computer education program at one high school as the type of learning kids need.More >>
Monday, December 9 2013 8:43 PM EST2013-12-10 01:43:09 GMT
"We are trying to create a few new affordable housing units so that people have a chance to move beyond shelter and regain their independence," said Rita Markley, Executive Director of the Committee onMore >>
COTS reaching out to Old North End neighbors in the development of new affordable housing and a daystation.More >>