The Vt. Supreme Court triggered a firestorm in its split ruling issued Friday that throws out the domestic assault conviction and a 12 to 20 year prison term for Michael Brillon, an habitual offender from Bennington.
A three-justice majority of Denise Johnson, John Dooley, and Marilyn Skoglund determined that the three years it took to get to trial had not satisfied Brillon's constitutional right to a speedy trial. They ruled the convictions must be vacated and the charges dismissed.
But in a bitter dissent, justices Bryan Burgess and Paul Reiber said the lions share of the delays were attributable to the defendant, not to the state.
"Well I have to say that I'm really surprised by this decision. It seems to me that the court, one: got the law wrong in that they really didn't explain how it was in any meaningful way that the defendant wasn't responsible for his own delays," said Cheryl Hanna of the Vt. Law School.
Hanna says the three-justice majority got the law wrong in this case and in so doing did a disservice to domestic abuse victims.
"The defendant here was continually delaying the trial, asking for new attorneys, as a way to further harass this victim, and as a way to, you know, further exert power and control. And a court that I think has usually been pretty good about understanding victims' rights really did not understand that context at all," explained Hanna.
Jennifer Fink works for Women Helping Battered Women, she too is dismayed by the ruling. She says it will send the wrong message to victims. "They're being, oftentimes being told by their offender, nobody's going to believe you, I'm going to get away with it, don't even bother to go to the police. If you're hearing these messages, this is going to reaffirm that."
The ruling also drew an anguished response from Gov. Jim Douglas, R-Vermont. He called the court ruling grossly irresponsible.
Saturday, March 8 2014 10:21 AM EST2014-03-08 15:21:27 GMT
Two firefighters are recovering from minor injuries. They were injured while fighting a at the Bennett Farm on Route 15 on the Johnson-Cambridge town line. The fire started in a shed around 7:30 FridayMore >>
Two firefighters are recovering from minor injuries.More >>
Saturday, March 8 2014 10:20 AM EST2014-03-08 15:20:42 GMT
Friends are rallying around families who lost everything in an apartment building fire in St. Johnsbury. They immediately took to Facebook after hearing about this fire and started planning to collectMore >>
Friends are rallying around families who lost everything in an apartment building fire in St. Johnsbury.More >>
Saturday, March 8 2014 10:20 AM EST2014-03-08 15:20:05 GMT
Reporter: "What are some of the most common burn injuries that we see with kids coming into the hospital?" Jim Esdon, Dartmouth Hitchcock Injury Prevention Center: "This time of year, the glass frontedMore >>
We've had another cold week that's left homeowners cranking the heat. But what does that mean for kids' safety?More >>
Saturday, March 8 2014 10:19 AM EST2014-03-08 15:19:21 GMT
Armed with just two L rods, 87-year-old John Wayne Blassingame starts looking for water by asking yes or no questions. "Does it go past 20 feet, does it go past 30 feet, yah," he says. The rods crossingMore >>
A national organization based in Danville says it is providing resources to people in desperate need to find water.More >>
Saturday, March 8 2014 8:31 AM EST2014-03-08 13:31:36 GMT
The Governor is traveling to Rhode Island Saturday. His office says Governor Peter Shumlin will be at Brown University in Providence taking part in a forum with the Rhode Island Governor. While theMore >>
The Governor is traveling to Rhode Island Saturday. More >>
Saturday, March 8 2014 8:17 AM EST2014-03-08 13:17:30 GMT
We have some ideas for your Saturday. IRISH FESTIVAL The 19th annual Burlington Irish Heritage Festival kicks off today. There is a lecture about the role of Irish immigrants in the Civil War at theMore >>
Friday, March 7 2014 7:28 PM EST2014-03-08 00:28:44 GMT
Williston Police say, the powder was from a generic prescription medication. They say, the man was from Burlington and had the paperwork in his pocket with his medicine and that's how it got on there. More >>
Williston Police say, the powder was from a generic prescription medication. They say, the man was from Burlington and had the paperwork in his pocket with his medicine and that's how it got on there.More >>