The Roman Catholic Diocese of Burlington is in court again, just months after losing a multi-million dollar verdict in a priest sex abuse case. Another man has filed a civil suit, saying he, too, was molested by the same priest in the 1970s.
In both cases, the lawsuit is not against the accused abuser, Father Edward Paquette. Instead, plaintiffs claim the diocese was negligent in hiring a known pedophile. The jury in the previous case awarded the plaintiff a record $8.7 million.
In court Wednesday, the attorney for the diocese did not deny that Father Edward Paquette molested young boys in his parish 30 years ago.
"It is illegal now, it was illegal then," Tom McCormick said. "It's wrong now, it was wrong then."
But McCormick said the diocese should not be held liable. He asked the jury to consider this case in the context of the 1970s -- when medical knowledge, psychology and awareness of abuse were not what they are now.
"You will not see any evidence of recklessness or malice," he said. "You may see mistakes, you may see decisions you disagree with particularly with the lens of hindsight, but you won't see malice."
But the plaintiff's attorney argued that the Burlington diocese knew before they hired him that Paquette had a history of homosexual relationships with young boys in other states. Jerry O'Neill showed the jury a 1972 letter from Paquette's former diocese in Indiana regarding three incidents over six years. It raised concerns about keeping Paquette in that diocese.
"The territory is not large enough to provide another assignment," O'Neill read, "and the risk of scandal is thus aggravated." The writer recommended Paquette be assigned not to a parish, but to an "institutional chaplaincy with less likelihood of relapse."
The arguments by each attorney were largely the same that were made during the first sex abuse lawsuit three months ago.
The jury in that case found the diocese liable and awarded the plaintiff $8.7 million.
"After that record-setting verdict, it seems to me the defense must just be hoping they'll win these cases on appeal on a legal issue," said Cheryl Hanna, a professor at Vermont Law School. She said the diocese faces an uphill battle and expects the outcome of this and future suits to be the same as the last.
"Every case has its own unique set of facts," she said. "Given that, however, it strikes me that much of what the jury is going to learn in this case, about the father, about what the diocese knew, are going to be very, very similar."
Last month, the diocese did settle out of court with another of Father Paquette's alleged victims. But Hanna said there's not much of an incentive for plaintiffs to do that. They're hoping for a sizable jury award, and they want their day in court -- what Hanna describes as a "cathartic part of the healing process."
After this trial there will still be 24 more abuse cases pending against the church, 15 of them involving Paquette.
Saturday, May 18 2013 10:10 PM EDT2013-05-19 02:10:53 GMT
A fatal accident in Lyndon Saturday. It happened around 2:30 Saturday afternoon on Route 122. Police say 76-year-old Gerda Blaszczyk of St. Johnsbury swerved to avoid an animal. Her car travelled up anMore >>
Police say the driver swerved to avoid an animal.More >>
Saturday, May 18 2013 8:03 PM EDT2013-05-19 00:03:45 GMT
Senator Bernie Sanders is touring the state this weekend with a special guest. Sanders and the Danish Ambassabdor to the United States are hosting town hall meetings in Burlington, Brattleboro and Montpelier. TheMore >>
Sanders and the Danish Ambassabdor to the United States are hosting town hall meetings.More >>
Saturday, May 18 2013 7:56 PM EDT2013-05-18 23:56:03 GMT
Saturday marked a new beginning for Castleton State College students. "Were all gathered here, getting fired up, having a good time," explained Castleton graduate, David Carrier. The 500 graduates hadMore >>
It's graduation day for the class of 20-13 at Castleton State College. And just for the occasion, the college invited back an alumnus with a strong connection to the school.More >>
Saturday, May 18 2013 7:51 PM EDT2013-05-18 23:51:53 GMT
State police are looking for the person responsible for stealing a school bus and taking it for a joyride in northern Vermont. Troopers say the 2014-model bus belonging Newport City Elementary SchoolMore >>
Police say the school bus belonging to the Newport City Elementary School was taken for a joy ride Friday night.More >>
Saturday, May 18 2013 7:51 PM EDT2013-05-18 23:51:14 GMT
Young bikers were learning the rules of the road in South Burlington Saturday. Kids who brought their bikes to the Dorset St. Park received free checks for their brakes, chains, and tires. Helmets alsoMore >>
and much more... making sure kids are safe before they hit the roads this summer.More >>
Saturday, May 18 2013 7:49 PM EDT2013-05-18 23:49:26 GMT
On a sun-soaked Saturday, Karen Trayah and her dogs enjoyed the sights, sounds, and of course smells of a festival for fidos. "It's called Woofstock, however, this is our 1st year doing it here at theMore >>
Making sure our furry friends have a place to call home.More >>
Friday, May 17 2013 7:54 PM EDT2013-05-17 23:54:10 GMT
The door to room 118 at the Liberty Inn and Suites is gone-- busted by police during an early morning drug raid. They say tenant Julie Herron, 41, was selling heroin out her room. She was living thereMore >>
A South Burlington drug bust exposed new abuses of the state's homeless voucher program. A couple was arrested for selling heroin out of their motel room, and police say the state was footing the bill for their stay.More >>
Friday, May 17 2013 7:56 PM EDT2013-05-17 23:56:29 GMT
A public defender entered 34-year-old Anthony Wright's not guilty plea in the Chittenden County courthouse Friday morning. Police say a search of Wright's residence two days earlier revealed about 250More >>
A Burlington man denies drug charges after police say they stumbled upon his marijuana grow operation. It happened while authorities were investigating another alleged drug crime next door.More >>