WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-Tenn. pastor arraigned in custody dispute

Tenn. pastor arraigned in custody dispute

Timothy Miller Timothy Miller
Janet Jenkins Janet Jenkins

Burlington, Vermont - April 25, 2011

A Tennessee pastor was in federal court in Burlington Monday morning charged with helping a former Vermont woman involved in a lesbian custody dispute.

Timothy Miller had no words for Channel 3 News as he left the Burlington Federal District courtroom Monday. Authorities believe he helped Lisa Miller -- they are not related. Miller fled to Nicaragua with her biological daughter Isabella to avoid a court order that she turn over custody of the girl to her former civil union partner Janet Jenkins.

"I believe that my higher power is going to bring her back to me -- safe. And this, clearly, is in the right direction," she said.

Lisa Miller and Janet Jenkins were joined in a Vermont civil union in 2000. Isabella was born to Miller and the couple broke up shortly after. Miller renounced homosexuality, became an evangelical Christian and moved to Virginia. She was originally granted custody of Isabella, but her refusal to obey orders granting Jenkins visitation led to a protracted court fight. Eventually full custody of Isabella was granted to Jenkins. But rather than hand over the child, Miller took Isabella and fled to Nicaragua. Now Jenkins wants answers.

"I certainly think that anyone that has helped have my daughter taken to a third world country where she doesn't eat the food, she doesn't speak the language. She's basically being kept in a house," Jenkins said.

Timothy Miller is described by authorities as a pastor in an Mennonite church. He's charged with aiding in international parental kidnapping, which carries a potential three-year prison term. He's accused of providing Lisa Miller and the girl with travel assistance and a place to live outside the U.S. The FBI says Timothy Miller has family in Nicaragua. It has been more than two years since Jenkins has seen her daughter. The Jenkins family says they will wait as long as it takes to be reunited with Isabella.

"We pray for her safe return everyday. Everyday -- everyday," Jenkins said.

The FBI believes Lisa Miller and Isabella are still in Nicaragua. Timothy Miller will be back in Vermont for a probable cause hearing on May 10th.

Melinda Davenport - WCAX News

  • Local News

  • Sunday, May 20 2012 10:32 PM EDT2012-05-21 02:32:10 GMT
    Vermont -- the top "eat local" state in the country -- has a cornucopia of healthy eating options, and a new app is helping even more people find their local farms.Warm sunlight washed over the family-owned
    Vermont -- the top "eat local" state in the country -- has a cornucopia of healthy eating options, and a new app is helping even more people find their local farms.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 8:13 PM EDT2012-05-21 00:13:19 GMT
    Hot-shot bicyclists who ignore the law are asking for a traffic ticket in one Vermont town.
    Hot-shot bicyclists who ignore the law are asking for a traffic ticket in one Vermont town.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 8:11 PM EDT2012-05-21 00:11:59 GMT
    A total of 524 mobile homes were damaged in Vermont during Tropical Storm Irene. And many homeowners are still recovering, some paying more for housing.
    A total of 524 mobile homes were damaged in Vermont during Tropical Storm Irene. And many homeowners are still recovering, some paying more for housing.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 8:04 PM EDT2012-05-21 00:04:23 GMT
    The president Nickelodeon, the popular children's cable channel, provided the final lesson for UVM graduates Sunday.Cyma Zarghami, a former UVM student herself, delivered Sunday's commencement speech to
    The president of Nickelodeon, the popular childrens's cable channel, provided the final lesson for UVM graduates Sunday.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 8:01 PM EDT2012-05-21 00:01:18 GMT
    A massive search for a missing person in the Champlain Islands Sunday.       Around noon-- authorities in Alburgh received the report.  Vermont State Police, Border Patrol, the Sheriff's Department and
    A massive search for a missing person in the Champlain Islands Sunday.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 7:58 PM EDT2012-05-20 23:58:49 GMT
    Police say armed gunmen robbed a Burlington cab driver. The cabby told Burlington police two gunman robbed him near the intersection of Pine Street and Lyman Avenue just after two o'clock Saturday morning.
    Near the intersection of Pine Street and Lyman Avenue Saturday.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 7:58 PM EDT2012-05-20 23:58:16 GMT
    Vermont police say a 33-year-old motorist was distracted while writing a text message on his cellphone when he crashed into a police car.
    Vermont police say a 33-year-old motorist was distracted while writing a text message on his cellphone when he crashed into a police car.
  • Sunday, May 20 2012 7:28 PM EDT2012-05-20 23:28:13 GMT
    A suspicious fire at a home in Corinth Sunday.Officials say the call came in just before 8 a.m.  An abandoned home on Cookeville Road was fully engulfed.  Crews from five surrounding towns -- nearly 40
    A suspicious fire at a home in Corinth Sunday.