Quantcast

Does U.S. Supreme Court ruling put patient privacy at risk? - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

Does U.S. Supreme Court ruling put patient privacy at risk?

Montpelier, Vermont - June 24, 2011

A trip to the doctor's office may not be as private as you think.

"Why should a drug company be able to buy information about the prescriptions that a doctor thinks are good for me?" asked Rep. Mark Larson, D-Burlington.

Larson chairs the House health care committee. He says he's disappointed that the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a Vermont law that would have forbidden drug companies from gathering information on doctors' prescribing habits. The state argues that companies use the info to push doctors to use brand name over generic prescription drugs.

"From the health care cost containment aspect this is a real setback," Larson said.

Republicans say it's also a setback for Vermont. They've been an outspoken opponent to the Prescription Confidentiality Law.

"There was a lot of discussion on the House floor about the legality of it. About the constitutionality of the law itself," said Pat McDonald, the chair of the Vermont Republican Party.

In a 6-3 decision, the high court ruled that the Vermont law violates the free speech rights of pharmaceutical companies and data miners. It went on to say the law lacked coherence and careful crafting.

"The court was very critical of the state for saying we don't like the message of the pharmaceutical companies, we don't like their costs, and so we're going to censor them but nobody else," said Cheryl Hanna of the Vermont Law School.

Vermont has now argued two major cases before the U.S. Supreme Court in the last five years involving the First Amendment, capping campaign finances and now this.

"In both of those cases the Legislature took bold steps. They passed laws that were really pushing the envelope," Hanna said.

Legal analyst Cheryl Hannah explains in the face of an increasingly conservative court it was risky for Vermont to pass such a progressive law.

"This was a very good example of the Legislature trying to respond to new technologies by protecting privacy, on the other hand, when you are doing that you have to pay really close attention to the constitution," Hanna said.

In this case Vermont lost that gamble and could now be on the hook to pay millions in legal fees.

Jennifer Reading - WCAX News

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Police: Men used stolen cards on thousands of dollars in purchases

    Police: Men used stolen cards on thousands of dollars in purchases

    Saturday, August 23 2014 9:48 AM EDT2014-08-23 13:48:46 GMT
    Police in Chittenden County have caught two men from Brooklyn who they say used stolen credit card numbers to buy thousands of dollars worth of stuff.
    Police in Chittenden County have caught two men from Brooklyn who they say used stolen credit card numbers to buy thousands of dollars worth of stuff.
  • Destination Recreation: Clark's Trading Post

    Destination Recreation: Clark's Trading Post

    Saturday, August 23 2014 9:28 AM EDT2014-08-23 13:28:18 GMT
    Clark's Trading Post in Lincoln, New Hampshire has attracted millions of visitors since opening its doors in 1928. While famous for its bear shows, it offers a whole lot more.
    Clark's Trading Post in Lincoln, New Hampshire has attracted millions of visitors since opening its doors in 1928. While famous for its bear shows, it offers a whole lot more.

  • At Issue: Keeping up with kids' vaccinations

    At Issue: Keeping up with kids' vaccinations

    Saturday, August 23 2014 9:21 AM EDT2014-08-23 13:21:43 GMT
    It's about time to send kids back to school, and if you're a parent, chances are you've gotten a note reminding you to make sure your kids are up to date on their vaccinations.
    It's about time to send kids back to school, and if you're a parent, chances are you've gotten a note reminding you to make sure your kids are up to date on their vaccinations.
  • Teaching the notes of tango in Stowe

    Teaching the notes of tango in Stowe

    Saturday, August 23 2014 9:13 AM EDT2014-08-23 13:13:32 GMT
     The hills of Stowe were alive this week with the sound of music -- Argentine Tango music. We sent Cat Viglienzoni to check it out.
     The hills of Stowe were alive this week with the sound of music -- Argentine Tango music. We sent Cat Viglienzoni to check it out.
  • Burglary suspects caught

    Burglary suspects caught

    Saturday, August 23 2014 12:18 AM EDT2014-08-23 04:18:38 GMT
    Vermont State Police nabbed a pair of suspected burglars and believe they're linked to several other crimes.
    Vermont State Police nabbed a pair of suspected burglars and believe they're linked to several other crimes.
  • Sen. Jim Jeffords laid to rest

    Sen. Jim Jeffords laid to rest

    Friday, August 22 2014 8:12 PM EDT2014-08-23 00:12:17 GMT
    Sen. Jim Jeffords was one of Vermont's beloved public servants, with a career that took him from the hills of Shrewsbury to the U.S. Senate. Friday, in his hometown of Rutland, James Jeffords was laid to rest.
    Sen. Jim Jeffords was one of Vermont's beloved public servants, with a career that took him from the hills of Shrewsbury to the U.S. Senate. Friday, in his hometown of Rutland, James Jeffords was laid to rest.
  • Is it safe to move accused killer Elizabeth Teague?

    Is it safe to move accused killer Elizabeth Teague?

    Friday, August 22 2014 7:09 PM EDT2014-08-22 23:09:17 GMT
    The Vt. Dept. of Mental Health says scarce resources are part of the push to relocate alleged workplace shooter Elizabeth Teague to a facility with fewer regulations. Elizabeth Keatinge was at Friday's hearing.
    The Vt. Dept. of Mental Health says scarce resources are part of the push to relocate alleged workplace shooter Elizabeth Teague to a facility with fewer regulations. Elizabeth Keatinge was at Friday's hearing.
  • Police investigate death of 13-year-old in Hardwick

    Police investigate death of 13-year-old in Hardwick

    Friday, August 22 2014 8:10 PM EDT2014-08-23 00:10:40 GMT
    Investigators say a teen was found dead at a home in Hardwick Friday morning.
    Investigators say a teen was found dead at a home in Hardwick Friday morning.
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.