In opening statements Monday to Federal Judge J. Garvan Murtha, Entergy's lead lawyer claimed that safety of Vermont's only nuclear power plant is at the core of the company's case. A matter, she said, that can only be regulated by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
The NRC has already re-licensed Vermont Yankee for another 20 years past the 2012 closure date and legal experts say the state has an uphill battle trying to shut Yankee down.
"They have the constitutional duty to prove that they would have done the exact same thing if they weren't regulating for safety reasons, so again, it's really shifting the burden to the state to really make out its case," said Cheryl Hanna with Vermont Law School.
Last year Vermont lawmakers overwhelming voted not to issue the power plant a certificate of public good to keep operating. Assistant Attorney General Scott Kline stated that the case is not about safety and rather about bad business practices and Entergy's unwillingness to follow Vermont law.
Much of Monday's witness testimony focused on economics. Two senior level Entergy employees explained how the company is a wholesale nuclear plant selling power all over the New England grid. Which means Vermont rate payers are not directly at risk.
"Essentially the state doesn't need Entergy and Entergy doesn't need the state, and because that message came out fairly clearly, that Entergy doesn't need the state and the state doesn't need Entergy, it really undermines the state's argument that it is regulating for economic reasons," Hannah said.
But others disagree. "I think the state has a very strong case here," said Sandra Levine with the Conservation Law Foundation. She says the case is simply about business and a deep mistrust between the parties. "Bottom line -- Entergy was not going to be a favorable partner for the state of Vermont going forward and the state has every right to consider that and act on that," Levine said.
The President of Entergy, John Herron, who was the first witness to take the stand, declined comment leaving court.
Legal experts say the judge is likely to take his time with the ruling. It could come in about a month's time. Because they say an appeal is probable no matter which side comes out on top.
Tuesday, May 21 2013 12:41 PM EDT2013-05-21 16:41:46 GMT
The Vermont couple charged with killing a Saint Johnsbury teacher will be in court Tuesday and are planning on asking for new lawyers. Prosecutors say Allen and Patricia Prue kidnapped and killed 33-year-oldMore >>
A Vermont judge has denied a request for a new lawyer by a woman charged, along with her husband, with killing a popular St. Johnsbury teacher.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 12:36 PM EDT2013-05-21 16:36:47 GMT
A former animal control officer charged with two counts of prohibited acts was arraigned Tuesday morning. Gary Francis is accused of asking two women to show him their breasts for money. Francis pleadedMore >>
A former animal control officer charged with asking women to show him their breasts for money was arraigned Tuesday.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 10:03 AM EDT2013-05-21 14:03:49 GMT
A Middlebury man has pleaded not guilty to federal arson charges stemming from a fire at a Pittsford car dealership back in July 2011. Police said they found 29-year-old Steven Browne behind the wheelMore >>
A Middlebury man has pleaded not guilty to federal arson charges stemming from a fire at a Pittsford car dealership back in July 2011.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 12:37 PM EDT2013-05-21 16:37:40 GMT
The big story nationally is the aftermath of the disastrous tornado that struck Moore, Okla., Monday. Search and rescue efforts are taking place all over the devastated suburban community. Dozens uponMore >>
In the wake of a devastating tornado, Vt. Gov. Peter Shumlin issued a statement offering sympathy and support to Oklahoma.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 10:06 AM EDT2013-05-21 14:06:59 GMT
A historic building in North Bennington will have new owners and a new purpose. Merchant's Bank donated the building to the Fund for North Bennington and the Preservation Trust of Vermont. That buildingMore >>
A historic building in North Bennington will have new owners and a new purpose.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 10:09 AM EDT2013-05-21 14:09:03 GMT
Work on a chain reaction road project is in full swing starting in Northfield. Crews are working on the final coat of pavement on Route 12 and 12A, and hope to wrap up shortly. The next phase in RandolphMore >>
Work on a chain reaction road project is in full swing starting in Northfield.More >>
Tuesday, May 21 2013 12:38 PM EDT2013-05-21 16:38:29 GMT
Do you know how much time your children or grandchildren spend in phys ed? Where you live in Vermont can make a big difference in answering that question. This week on the Channel 3 News at 6 p.m., EducationMore >>
Do you know how much time your children or grandchildren spend in phys ed? Where you live in Vermont can make a big difference in answering that question.More >>