An unusual case before the Supreme Court Tuesday. The father of 12-year-old Brooke Bennett says the little girl's aunt is partially responsible for Brooke's death, and he wants her insurance company to pay.
Brooke Bennett's father, James, says Woodward acted negligently for allowing the little girl around Woodward's former husband, Michael Jacques. Jacques is awaiting trial for the alleged kidnapping, sexual assault and murder of 12-year-old Brooke. James Bennett wants Woodward's insurance company to cover the bodily injury and his suffering. Tuesday, his attorney took the case to the Vermont Supreme Court.
"The allegation is that she failed to exercise reasonable care in the protection of her niece, that she was negligent," said Paul Perkins, James Bennett's attorney.
The case made it to Vermont's top judges after it worked its way through the trial court. That court ruled that Woodward's policy does not cover the little girl's alleged kidnapping, sexual assault and murder for three reasons:
First the incident was an intentional act and not an accident. Second, the act was an intentional act by the insured. And third, there was no "bodily injury" because the harm resulted from "sexual molestation of a person."
Robin Cooley, the attorney for the Co-operative Insurance Company, told the justices, "Bodily injury per our definition does not mean harm or death that arises out of the actual alleged or threatened sexual molestation of a person."
James Bennett's attorney told the court that the homeowner's insurance policy covers Woodward and Jacques as individuals, arguing Woodward's alleged negligence is independent of Jacques' alleged behavior.
"The purpose of the clause is to ensure that each of the insured are treated separately in the determination of coverage and the application of exclusion," Perkins said.
It could take 90 days before the Supreme Court issues a ruling in this case.
Woodward and Bennett were not in the courtroom Tuesday. We did not reach the insurance company's lawyer for comment. Bennett's lawyer declined our request for an interview.
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:27 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:27:22 GMT
Town meeting day didn't bode well for dozens of school budgets across the state. Now the Burlington City Council is looking to cut costs after voters rejected school spending hikes. The council votedMore >>
Town meeting day didn't bode well for dozens of school budgets across the state. Now the Burlington City Council is looking to cut costs after voters rejected school spending hikes.More >>
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:26 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:26:45 GMT
The Vermont Senate has loosened restrictions on the state's medical marijuana dispensaries. The bill passed Tuesday allows an unlimited number of qualified Vermonters to access medical marijuana -- removing theMore >>
The Vermont Senate has loosened restrictions on the state's medical marijuana dispensaries.More >>
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:26 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:26:03 GMT
A St. George man is behind bars accused of stealing from an elderly South Burlington woman. 43-year-old Craig Dubuque was arrested for the alleged financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult. Police sayMore >>
A St. George man is behind bars accused of stealing from an elderly South Burlington woman.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 11:35 PM EDT2014-03-12 03:35:07 GMT
"You know, people say you might not need it, which is true, but this way you get a choice. I don't have to go out tomorrow," said Lorinda Henry of Milton. Henry says she hit the grocery stores TuesdayMore >>
Parts of Vermont could get up to 24 inches of snow in the coming storm. And VTrans officials are warning drivers they may not be able to keep up with the storm rolling in Wednesday.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 8:02 PM EDT2014-03-12 00:02:07 GMT
"Seems like it was just yesterday. Doesn't seem like it's been two years at all," said Glenda Reandeau of Tupper Lake. Residents of Tupper Lake still have their eyes out for Colin Gillis, a now 20-year-oldMore >>
Colin Gillis of Tupper Lake, N.Y., disappeared two years ago. And authorities are still searching for him. They say the investigation now focuses on tips from the public and from those who were the last to see Gillis.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 6:17 PM EDT2014-03-11 22:17:43 GMT
A Rutland City Police officer is recovering at home after a crash involving his cruiser. Authorities say Officer Adam Lucia was one of two officers responding to an aggravated assault call Monday at TopsMore >>
A Rutland City Police officer is recovering at home after a crash involving his cruiser.More >>