Montpelier and Berlin are negotiating over access to the pond that supplies the area's drinking water.
This May, the state supreme court threw out an ordinance banning recreational access to the water. The city and town of met again Monday night, as they try to come to terms on how to proceed following that ruling.
Scenic Berlin Pond provides all of Montpelier's drinking water, and most of the town of Berlin's. It's long been a favorite site for walkers and joggers. Now, boaters also turnout following the Vermont Supreme Court's May decision.
Montpelier owns all but 0.25 percent of the property surrounding the pond. The city's council-members say they can prevent use of the water by the public, if Montpelier and Berlin enforce no trespassing restrictions on the lands surrounding the pond.
"We're very curious what you're going to do with that 85 feet," said Montpelier councilman Andrew Hooper as he addressed his Berlin counterparts and their plans for town owned property.
"I really wouldn't want to to put access just anywhere because I can," A Berlin selectman responded, "I'd want to put access in the best place for everybody on that pond."
Berlin select board members, unlike Montpelier's officials, say they're hesitant to wiggle around the Supreme Court's decision granting access. The board is considering a range of options for their small parcel like a pay-to-park site.
Montpelier could rent the land and ban access; the state could lease the property and install a boat ramp.
As the officials discussed the latter, Select Board Chairman Brad Towne asked about how light-recreational use would affect water quality. "What is the filtration capacity of the (water treatment) plant," he asked, "what contaminants will it take out?"
"I think it will take out a lot, it's a fairly sophisticated plant, but there are many that it wouldn't," said Montpelier Mayor John Hollar, "I don't think we have an answer, a complete answer for all the risk that might result."
Those in attendance voiced opinions as divided as the board's and council's.
"It is easy to restrict access to non-motorized use and I think most of the people who have been accessing the pond would support that," said Williamstown resident Michael Covey, "I think you'd find very few who don't support that."
"There are enough other ponds around this state to use boats, kayaks," said Montpelier resident Barbara White, "I think risking the security and the safety of drinking water is big."
If the debate remains so contentious, the matter may land back in front of a judge again soon. According to the state website of the Water Supply Division, Vermont began protecting public water sources the late 1970s.
Friday, March 7 2014 11:46 AM EST2014-03-07 16:46:45 GMT
Related Stories: O'Hagan children attend playground dedication Charges coming in Pat O'Hagan murder? Clock runs out on some potential charges in O'Hagan case Frustration over unsolved murder at SheffieldMore >>
The Caledonia County state's attorney is filing paperwork to bring murder charges against three men in the 2010 murder of Sheffield grandmother Pat O'Hagan. More >>
Friday, March 7 2014 3:04 PM EST2014-03-07 20:04:45 GMT
Police are investigating a suspicious package in Williston. Investigators say the parcel with an unknown white powder inside was found at a building on Hurricane Lane. The building was evacuated. WillistonMore >>
Officials say a suspicious package that prompted evacuations at a building on Hurricane Lane in Williston Friday contained starch.More >>
Friday, March 7 2014 3:19 PM EST2014-03-07 20:19:54 GMT
A threat canceled all after-school activities in the Colchester School District Friday. The superintendent sent out an alert to parents saying even with enhanced security measures, the district considersMore >>
A threat canceled all after-school activities in the Colchester School District Friday.More >>
Friday, March 7 2014 10:42 AM EST2014-03-07 15:42:34 GMT
The state of Vermont released new evidence in hopes of keeping a Manchester woman behind bars. Fifty-year-old Patricia Kane was arrested on charges of interfering with the custody of a minor in January.More >>
The state of Vermont released new evidence in hopes of keeping a Manchester woman behind bars.More >>
Friday, March 7 2014 12:27 PM EST2014-03-07 17:27:43 GMT
Investigators say a late-night fire at the old Burlington Free Press building was an act of arson. A fire alarm went off in the College Street property at 11:20 p.m. Thursday. Fire crews found a smallMore >>
Investigators say a late-night fire at the old Burlington Free Press building was an act of arson.More >>
Friday, March 7 2014 2:03 PM EST2014-03-07 19:03:49 GMT
A Swanton man was injured Friday in an explosion and fire in the garage at his home on Church Street. Police say Warren Caswell called 911 just after 10 a.m. to report a propane explosion and fire. HeMore >>
A Swanton man was injured Friday in an explosion and fire in the garage at his home on Church Street.More >>