Nestled in the hills of Duxbury is the picturesque Moose Meadow Lodge. For Marlene Gutierrez and Gwen Castilla it was the perfect wedding venue.
"We've been dreaming about getting married ever since we first met," Gutierrez said.
Their dream came true Monday, when the Virginia couple was legally married in Vermont. But these newlyweds face an uphill battle.
"It's disappointing because we would like to commence our life together but there will be restriction," Gutierrez said.
Castilla is a foreign national from the Philippines; her new wife is a U.S. citizen. Since the federal government does not legally recognize their marriage, Castilla will be forced to leave the country in six months when her visa expires.
This is one of 1,100 federal marriage benefits withheld from gay couples under the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act or DOMA, which bars federal agencies from recognizing the validity of same-sex marriages. But the constitutionality of that federal law is being debated in the country's highest court.
"What the court decides from the case today, will affect literally thousands of Vermonters," said Cheryl Hanna of the Vermont Law School.
Legal expert Hanna says the Supreme Court will have until June to decide if same-sex couples should be entitled to the same marriage rights as straight couples.
Vermont has been instrumental in the debate since the beginning. It was the first state to allow civil unions for same-sex couples 13 years ago and legalized same-sex marriage in 2009. Since then, 941 gay and lesbian Vermonters have gotten married. And 1,788 out-of-staters have come here to tie the knot.
Greg Trulson married Vermont's first same-sex couple. He and his husband, Willie Docto, are also the innkeepers at Moose Meadow.
"The Defense of Marriage Act affects us tremendously," Docto said.
They say DOMA prevents them from jointly filing their taxes, getting equal medical benefits, making end of life choices and having access to one another in hospitals-- challenges they would not face if they were married to women.
"It's just that we're two guys," Trulson said. "But our marriage should be exactly the same as any other couple."
"Same-sex unions serve the best interests of nobody," Craig Bensen said.
Bensen is a longtime opponent of gay marriage. He says if DOMA is repealed there would be a fiscal, political and moral meltdown in the U.S. He calls same-sex marriage a radical change with no proven track record.
"It's not tried, it's not true. And just going there, as a massive social experiment, is not going to be something that's good for the country and for the country's children," Bensen said.
Gutierrez and Castilla disagree. They say their love is real.
"This marriage is really, really important for me," Gutierrez said. "This will be the next stage of my life and hopefully I can keep it forever."
Their fate and where they call home is now in the hands of the nine Supreme Court justices.
During arguments, five justices indicated they may view DOMA as unconstitutional, but for different reasons.
Same-sex marriages are legal in nine states and the District of Columbia. Hanna says it's unlikely the Supreme Court will make a ruling with national implications. Instead it will likely be a decision tailored to those states that already allow it.
Thursday, March 6 2014 11:41 PM EST2014-03-07 04:41:04 GMT
The Randolph man who admitted to murdering his niece in 2008 will be sentenced this spring. In August Michael Jacques struck a deal with federal prosecutors. He gave up his right to an appeal and pleadedMore >>
The Randolph man who admitted to murdering his niece in 2008 will be sentenced this spring.More >>
Thursday, March 6 2014 11:40 PM EST2014-03-07 04:40:13 GMT
It's a real estate deal between UVM and the Queen City that could end up kicking some non-profits to the curb. The Burlington School District voted Thursday night on half of the multi-million dollar deal.More >>
It's a real estate deal between UVM and the Queen City that could end up kicking some non-profits to the curb.More >>
Thursday, March 6 2014 7:53 PM EST2014-03-07 00:53:09 GMT
'Tis the season-- as winter winds down frost heaves and potholes arrive. The ups and downs of the 2014 winter can be seen and felt. No route or road is spared. And just adding to the frustration-- theMore >>
The deep freeze is making for some rough roads across our region and it's also contributing to a fuel shortage. Shelby Cashman has more.More >>
Thursday, March 6 2014 7:56 PM EST2014-03-07 00:56:36 GMT
The pothole problem knows no boundaries. Our neighbors to the north are also dealing with rough roads. The Quebec Transportation Ministry budgeted $260 million for winter road maintenance. But crews haveMore >>
Our neighbors to the north are also dealing with rough roads.More >>
Thursday, March 6 2014 4:23 PM EST2014-03-06 21:23:33 GMT
Investigators now say a fire that damaged a student housing complex at St. Michael's College was not caused by the building's heating system. The fire last month damaged a row of townhouses. All of theMore >>
Investigators now say a fire that damaged a student housing complex at St. Michael's College was not caused by the building's heating system.More >>
Thursday, March 6 2014 4:50 PM EST2014-03-06 21:50:24 GMT
Vermont police say a New Hampshire woman was driving drunk with two kids in her car. The incident happened Wednesday at the Intersection of 1-91 and Route 302 in Newbury, Vt. Vermont state police sayMore >>
Vermont police say a New Hampshire woman was driving drunk with two kids in her car.More >>