Will suspects in Pat O'Hagan murder ever face charges? - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

Will suspects in Pat O'Hagan murder ever face charges?

Posted: Updated:
Pat O'Hagan Pat O'Hagan
Michael Norrie Michael Norrie
Richard Fletcher Richard Fletcher

"It's right up there the top of the list of frustrating cases," said Bill Sorrell, D-Vt. Attorney General.

Investigators say they've had three suspects in Pat O'Hagan's death since shortly after the Sheffield grandmother was found murdered in 2010. Michael Norrie, Richard Fletcher and Keith Baird, all of Sheffield, are jailed on separate charges in other cases. Investigators say Fletcher and Norrie have implicated themselves in the murder and disposal of O'Hagan's body. The motive-- apparently that O'Hagan discovered a meth-making operation next door to her home. 

The men told prosecutors O'Hagan was raped and shot in the back of the head.

"Terrible tragedy," Sorrell said. "Wonderful woman who met a very unfortunate death."

Federal court filings against Fletcher in a child pornography case reveal both Norrie and Fletcher knew details about the case that only the killers would know. Fletcher told investigators things like how O'Hagan was shot, the type of gun, that her body was not buried, where it was and other specifics.

And federal prosecutors hoping for a tough sentence in the porn case say the state does not plan to charge Fletcher with murder because there's not enough evidence. Federal prosecutors wrote: "It is expected that this Court will be the only Court to address Fletcher's responsibility for O'Hagan's demise."

"I didn't read that in there," Sorrell said.

We showed Attorney General Bill Sorrell the federal filing. He disagrees.

"That's the U.S. Attorney's office saying that and again, I remain hopeful that we will gather enough evidence," Sorrell said.

Asked what he would need to charge them, Sorrell answered, "I'm not going to go into that. Again, if we charge someone and they are acquitted and then go out on the courthouse steps and confess, there's nothing we can do. That would be a double tragedy."

The pile of details has some close to O'Hagan frustrated that there have been no charges. But former federal prosecutor Jerry O'Neill says investigators are right to wait.

"You have three of them with pending charges. Once those charges get worked through, one or more of them is going to cooperate against the others and state or federal prosecutor will have what they need to bring murder charges," O'Neill said.

And Sorrell says there is no statute of limitations, so prosecutors can bring charges anytime they feel they have enough evidence.

Related Stories:

Court documents: 3 suspects in custody in Pat O'Hagan's death

Judge: Sheffield man's comments on Pat O'Hagan's death usable

Police again search home of murder victim Pat O'Hagan

Second cop testifies about confession in Vt. killing

Vt. police publicly acknowledge partial confession in O'Hagan case

Detective: Man was confessing in Pat O'Hagan murder

Police say more than 1 involved in Pat O'Hagan's murder

Unsolved murder leaves void in Sheffield

Police search for evidence near Pat O'Hagan's house

O'Hagan family, Vt. police mark 3 month murder investigation

Students pay tribute to Vt. murder victim

Tears, memories shared at Pat O'Hagan's funeral

Body found in Wheelock ID'd as Pat O'Hagan

Police: Body found in Wheelock is likely O'Hagan

Sheffield residents devastated by discovery

Vigil held for Pat O'Hagan

Grandmother kidnapping case now 1 week old

Community comes together to support Pat O'Hagan

Helicopter scans NEK for clues in grandmother's abduction

NEK clings to hope for abducted grandmother

Police: Missing Vt. woman likely abducted

Police offer few details on NEK search

Police: Potential for foul play in Sheffield case

Missing woman in Sheffield

Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.