Quantcast

Man charged with killing 2 outside Hubbardton home - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

Man charged with killing 2 outside Hubbardton home

Posted: Updated:
Sylvester Labartino Sylvester Labartino
RUTLAND, Vt. -

The family of Shane and Chris Plummer couldn't hold back the tears as Sylvester Labartino, 70, was brought into court Thursday. Labartino is charged with two counts of second-degree murder. Police say he shot and killed Shane Plummer, 57, and his son, Chris Plummer, 26, outside of Labartino's rented Hubbardton home Wednesday afternoon.

"It just doesn't seem real - it just doesn't seem real," said Michelle Charron, Shane's sister.

Court documents say the Plummers had been hired by Labartino's landlord to do work at the property, and the landlord had told police he had been having trouble with his tenant over that issue. Earlier in the day, family members say the father and son had been to the property, but Labartino prevented them from doing maintenance work. The fatal encounter happened when police say Labartino returned from an appointment and found the electricians back at the house.

"He was a good hard worker and a good dad and a good brother," Charron said.

According to court papers, Shane Plummer may have seen his son shot. A call was placed to 911 from Shane Plummer's cellphone number saying, "I need help, my son has just been shot and he chased me out of my truck with a rifle."

"He was a good guy," Charron said. "He wouldn't hurt a fly-- maybe a fly, but would do anything mean or cruel to anybody."

Court documents show that Labartino has a laundry list of a rap sheet, including driving under the influence of drugs, disorderly conduct, DUI and extortion. His defense asked that his criminal record not be presented in court, as they did not fight the bail amount offered by the state.

Labartino's bail was set at $750,000 and he is being held at Marble Valley Correctional facility. If convicted, he faces a minimum of 20 years in prison.

Related Story:

Hubbardton man charged in double-murder

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Car Collides with Train

    Car Collides with Train

    Friday, July 21 2017 7:24 AM EDT2017-07-21 11:24:12 GMT
    Two people are said to be okay this morning after their car collided with a freight train in Colchester. State police say it happened on East Road around 11:30 last night, just under a mile from the Milton town line. Investigators say Sophia Knox was traveling northbound when she tried to turn around and her car got lodged on one of the rails. Knox and her passenger were able to get out of the car before the car was pushed 81 feet. Police say parts of East Road were closed down for ab...
    Two people are said to be okay this morning after their car collided with a freight train in Colchester. State police say it happened on East Road around 11:30 last night, just under a mile from the Milton town line. Investigators say Sophia Knox was traveling northbound when she tried to turn around and her car got lodged on one of the rails. Knox and her passenger were able to get out of the car before the car was pushed 81 feet. Police say parts of East Road were closed down for ab...
  • Fire at Centennial Field

    Fire at Centennial Field

    Friday, July 21 2017 12:46 AM EDT2017-07-21 04:46:56 GMT

    Firefighters battled flames at Centennial Field Thursday night.

    Firefighters battled flames at Centennial Field Thursday night.

  • Homicide victim's sister relieved by capture of wanted man

    Homicide victim's sister relieved by capture of wanted man

    Thursday, July 20 2017 7:05 PM EDT2017-07-20 23:05:49 GMT

    A nationwide manhunt for a person of interest in a Vermont homicide is over. Now, the victim's heartbroken twin sister feels some relief the man has been captured.

    A nationwide manhunt for a person of interest in a Vermont homicide is over. Now, the victim's heartbroken twin sister feels some relief the man has been captured.

  • Vt. man sentenced for repeated sex assaults on a child

    Vt. man sentenced for repeated sex assaults on a child

    Thursday, July 20 2017 7:11 PM EDT2017-07-20 23:11:44 GMT

    A disturbing case of child sex assault the judge called "horrendous." Now, a South Burlington man will spend decades behind bars. 

    A disturbing case of child sex assault the judge called "horrendous." Now, a South Burlington man will spend decades behind bars. 

  • Allegations of sexual misconduct at Vt. school

    Allegations of sexual misconduct at Vt. school

    Thursday, July 20 2017 12:30 PM EDT2017-07-20 16:30:20 GMT

    There are allegations of sexual misconduct against a Thetford Academy student. 

    There are allegations of sexual misconduct against a Thetford Academy student. 

  • Vt. man faces child cruelty charges

    Vt. man faces child cruelty charges

    Thursday, July 20 2017 5:03 PM EDT2017-07-20 21:03:10 GMT

    Police say a Pawlet man was spinning a knife around a rope when the knife hit a child. 

    Police say a Pawlet man was spinning a knife around a rope when the knife hit a child. 

  • Bicyclist in serious condition after crash

    Bicyclist in serious condition after crash

    Thursday, July 20 2017 3:28 PM EDT2017-07-20 19:28:43 GMT

    Milton police are investigating a collision between a car and a bicycle.

    Milton police are investigating a collision between a car and a bicycle.

  • Helicopter rescues teen from NH mountaintop

    Helicopter rescues teen from NH mountaintop

    Thursday, July 20 2017 9:53 AM EDT2017-07-20 13:53:40 GMT

    A teenage girl is recovering after being rescued by helicopter from New Hampshire's Mount Monadnock.

    A teenage girl is recovering after being rescued by helicopter from New Hampshire's Mount Monadnock.

Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.