Was Vt. man's death murder or suicide? - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

Was Vt. man's death murder or suicide?

Posted: Updated:
HYDE PARK, Vt. -

Police say it was a single stab wound to the abdomen that killed a Hyde Park man last week. The victim's girlfriend is behind bars charged with his killing. But is there new evidence that could clear Jeanette Maxfield?

For officers on the scene it appeared to be a clear-cut murder case. Chris Cafferky, 48, was dead, police found a large knife on the table next to his body, and the only other person in the house told them "I'm afraid I may have done this."

Nearly two weeks after Cafferky's death there is new speculation about how he died.

"There was no evidence linking her directly to the knife," said David Sleigh, Maxfield's lawyer.

Last week, she was charged with Cafferky's murder. Maxfield, 23, told police she was drinking, blacked out and doesn't remember what happened to her boyfriend. She denied the charges in court. But prosecutors say she's the one who reported his death and was covered in Cafferky's blood.

"At that time Ms. Maxfield had blood on her body. They were able to obtain some clothing that Ms. Maxfield had worn earlier in the day that was also covered in blood," Lamoille County Deputy State's Attorney Todd Shove said Feb. 18.

"Given the lack of multiple stab wounds it may well have been suicide," Sleigh said.

Now, Maxfield's lawyer is suggesting that Cafferky may have killed himself. Sleigh is pointing to observations of officers at the scene and the medical examiner's report. Maxfield's lawyer got a video from the scene admitted into evidence Thursday that allegedly contains a conversation between police regarding the location of Cafferky's wound.

"The officers discussing the fact that this may well have been suicide, that there were no defensive wounds of any sort on Mr. Cafferky," Sleigh said.

Sleigh claims the fatal wound is in a spot that could indicate Cafferky stabbed himself. He says that, coupled with the fact that the Hyde Park man was recently hospitalized for suicidal thoughts, creates reasonable doubt in the murder case.

"So absent any other evidence of the mechanics of the stabbing, we argued today that it's sort of a 50-50 proposition with no greater weight falling on either side of the scale at this point," Sleigh explained.

We reached out to prosecutors. They would not comment on these latest allegations.

Maxfield told police she has multiple personalities and was diagnosed a borderline personality and mood disorder last year. She's currently being held without bail. Her lawyer asked the judge to reconsider that during Thursday's weight of the evidence hearing. The judge is taking the request under advisement. Sleigh expects a decision within a few days.

Click here to read the police affidavit and a transcript of the 911 call.

Related Stories:

Vt. woman pleads not guilty in boyfriend's stabbing death

Woman arrested in murder of Hyde Park man

WCAX Investigates: Did a St. Johnsbury prison guard cross the line?

WCAX Investigates: Are laws needed to protect parolees?

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • People's United: Retirement Plan Updates

    People's United: Retirement Plan Updates

    Thursday, April 24 2014 7:45 AM EDT2014-04-24 11:45:35 GMT
    The Internal Revenue Service is requiring companies to update their retirement plan documents.More >>
    The Internal Revenue Service is requiring companies to update their retirement plan documents.More >>
  • Rutland pharmacist accused of stealing meds

    Rutland pharmacist accused of stealing meds

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:43 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:43:47 GMT
    In Rutland a pharmacist is accused of stealing meds from his employer. 32-year-old Brandon Cigana worked at the Walgreens Pharmacy on Woodstock Avenue. Prosecutors say he used his position there to access the pharmacy's inventory stealing regulated drugs like benzodiazepines, Hydrocodone and Suboxone for himself without a prescription. The Whitehall, New York man faces up to two years behind bars.More >>
    In Rutland a pharmacist is accused of stealing meds from his employer. 32-year-old Brandon Cigana worked at the Walgreens Pharmacy on Woodstock Avenue. Prosecutors say he used his position there to access the pharmacy's inventory stealing regulated drugs like benzodiazepines, Hydrocodone and Suboxone for himself without a prescription. The Whitehall, New York man faces up to two years behind bars.More >>
  • Drug bust in Burlington's Old North End

    Drug bust in Burlington's Old North End

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:44 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:44:04 GMT
    Police made a drug bust Wednesday night in Burlington's Old North End. Police and the U.S. Marshal's raided this home on Cedar Street around 8 o'clock. They say they seized heroin and cocaine. Six people were inside when authorities went in. But they're not saying how many arrests were made. The raid was part of an ongoing drug investigation.More >>
    Police made a drug bust Wednesday night in Burlington's Old North End. Police and the U.S. Marshal's raided this home on Cedar Street around 8 o'clock. They say they seized heroin and cocaine. Six people were inside when authorities went in. But they're not saying how many arrests were made. The raid was part of an ongoing drug investigation.More >>
  • Fire damages Lyndonville tree farm

    Fire damages Lyndonville tree farm

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:44 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:44:21 GMT
    Fire has damaged ten acres of a Lyndonville tree farm. Eight department were called in to battle the blaze. And it took four hours to get the flames under control. Fire officals say a discarded cigarette combined with dry conditions are to blame. One firefighter suffered from minor smoke inhalation.More >>
    Fire has damaged ten acres of a Lyndonville tree farm. Eight department were called in to battle the blaze. And it took four hours to get the flames under control. Fire officals say a discarded cigarette combined with dry conditions are to blame. One firefighter suffered from minor smoke inhalation.More >>
  • A warning for bird watchers: Give eagles space

    A warning for bird watchers: Give eagles space

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:44 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:44:36 GMT
    Bird watchers are being reminded to give nesting bald eagles plenty of space. The Vermont Fish Wildlife Department is urging anyone who sees a nesting eagle not to get closer than 300 feet. Activity too close to their nest can result in them abandoning their young. Harassing a bald eagle is illegal and a violation of the state endangered species statute.More >>
    Bird watchers are being reminded to give nesting bald eagles plenty of space. The Vermont Fish Wildlife Department is urging anyone who sees a nesting eagle not to get closer than 300 feet. Activity too close to their nest can result in them abandoning their young. Harassing a bald eagle is illegal and a violation of the state endangered species statute.More >>
  • Gun fired into New Haven home

    Gun fired into New Haven home

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:44 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:44:48 GMT
    Police are searching for who fired a gun into a home in New Haven. It happened late Tuesday night at 2420 Munger Street. Police say a bullet passed through a window of the home. Luckily no one was hurt. Investigators say a stop sign at the intersection of Munger Street and Cobble Road had also been shot. Anyone with information should call state police.More >>
    Police are searching for who fired a gun into a home in New Haven. It happened late Tuesday night at 2420 Munger Street. Police say a bullet passed through a window of the home. Luckily no one was hurt. Investigators say a stop sign at the intersection of Munger Street and Cobble Road had also been shot. Anyone with information should call state police.More >>
  • What triggered a shooting inside the Bennington police station?

    What triggered a shooting inside the Bennington police station?

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 6:57 PM EDT2014-04-23 22:57:35 GMT
    A Bennington man is in stable condition after being shot by an officer inside the Bennington Police Department. Investigators say Gregory Filo had a knife and was behaving erratically.More >>
    A Bennington man is in stable condition after being shot by an officer inside the Bennington Police Department. Investigators say Gregory Filo had a knife and was behaving erratically.More >>
  • Former Fortune 500 exec indicted in fatal NH crash

    Former Fortune 500 exec indicted in fatal NH crash

    A New Hampshire grand jury has indicted a former Fortune 500 executive on second-degree murder charges in connection with a crash that killed a Vermont couple in December.More >>
    A New Hampshire grand jury has indicted a former Fortune 500 executive on second-degree murder charges in a crash that killed a Vermont couple in December.More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.