McAllister takes the stand in sex crimes trial - WCAX.COM Local Vermont News, Weather and Sports-

McAllister takes the stand in sex crimes trial

Posted: Updated:

The sex crimes case against a former Vermont lawmaker has gone to the jury. Seven men and five women will now consider Norm McAllister's fate and they got more information than they expected after a surprise twist in the courtroom.

Friday, former state senator Norm McAllister's defense team called a surprise witness: the defendant himself. McAllister swore his accuser started their sexual relationship when he was overcome by grief following the recent death of his wife.

"My family was there, they were great, my friends were there off and on, they were great, but you need to be able to put your arms around someone and have them there differently than just friends," McAllister said.

In a taped conversation between McAllister and his accuser, he acknowledged she may have felt forced into sex. He says there's a simple explanation.

"We had a mutual agreement that if one of us wanted it, the other would try to accommodate," McAllister said.

The defense played the tape, pausing point-by-point to allow McAllister to explain away seemingly incriminating admissions.

He denied prostituting his former tenant and farmhand but only explained this clip by saying they discussed it.

Tape clip: "Using your p***y for something other than producing babies seemed like a viable option."

The prosecution didn't buy any of the explanations McAllister did give.

"English is your first language, right?" Franklin County Deputy State's Attorney John Lavoie asked.

Many of McAllister's innocent explanations created new contradictions with the tape and earlier testimony. Throughout the recording, McAllister says he doesn't understand or is confused, but that's not the case when the accuser suggests she ignored requests to stop and said she felt pain.

John Lavoie: On this tape, you don't deny that, right?

Norm McAllister: Yes.

Now that the case is in the jury's hands, the judge and lawyers dismissed an alternate to the jury-- that's basically person number 13. As he was leaving the courthouse, our Kyle Midura asked him how he would have decided this if he were still on the jury. He didn't want to share that information, so we still don't have any inkling how the jurors may be considering this case. They will deliberate it and they are expected to return a verdict one way or the other Friday night.

Related Stories:

Accuser takes the stand in McAllister sex crimes trial

Trial begins in McAllister sex crimes case

Jury selection continues in McAllister trial

McAllister trial delayed after jury selection runs long

McAllister sex crimes trial on schedule

Former Vt. senator's sex assault trial could be delayed

Lawyer asks judge to toss out former state senator sex assault case

McAllister allowed to withdraw sex assault plea

Bombshell in sex crimes case against McAllister

McAllister asks to withdraw plea deal in sex crime case

McAllister withdraws plea deal in sexual-favors case

Is a former Vt. senator reconsidering his plea deal in sex crime case?

Former Vt. senator faces jail time after taking plea deal in sex assault case

2nd McAllister rape trial set to begin this week

Sen. Norm McAllister loses re-election bid

Sex assault charges against McAllister dismissed in 1st trial

State senator faces his accuser in court

Jury selected in McAllister trial

McAllister sex crimes trial begins Wednesday

McAllister on the ballot for re-election

Vt. legislative committee upholds McAllister's suspension

State senator accused of sex assault challenges suspension

McAllister trial delayed until May; session may be over

Vt. Senate votes to suspend McAllister

Vermont Sen. McAllister prepares for suspension vote

Senate to vote on proposed McAllister suspension

Vt. Senate committee votes to suspend McAllister

Senate panel to vote on McAllister suspension resolution

Vt. lawmakers may suspend senator facing sex assault charges

If McAllister doesn't step down, lawmakers prepared to take action

Prosecutors won't drop sex charges against Vt. lawmaker

How Vermont senators responded to McAllister ouster question

VSP investigate death of alleged McAllister victim

Police: McAllister could face additional charges

McAllister resignation expected by Tuesday

Vt. state senator pleads not guilty in alleged sex-for-rent scheme

Seven Days: Vt. state senator arrest

State senator arrested and charged with sexual assault

Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WCAX. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.