The issue of self-defense came up this week when a North Hero man shot at a burglar inside his home. No one was hurt, but there is plenty of legal precedence for justifiable shootings in self-defense.
"I said, 'listen I am going to shoot you if you don't produce some hands right now,'" said Jim Melanson, who was packing a pistol when he surprised a burglar in his home this week.
Melanson did fire two shots, but he missed the thief who then escaped unharmed out a back window.
Reporter Brian Joyce: You shot to miss?
"Yes, it was a warning," Melanson replied. "He never produced a weapon. If he had produced a weapon he definitely would not have come out of the house without going in an ambulance."
But the would-be burglar left his car in Melanson's driveway-- leading to the arrest of Eric Edson, a career criminal who was out on parole.
"I had the right to shoot him right there on the spot," Melanson said. "I know that for a fact 'cause he was in my house."
"It falls in the classification of justifiable homicide. You have a right to take a life to protect yourself, to protect your family, and to suppress certain crimes," explained Peter Langrock, a longtime trial lawyer.
Langrock says Vermont law permits the use of deadly force anywhere-- even outside the home-- if the person under attack believes they or loved ones are in imminent danger.
"Simply seeing somebody breaking into an outbuilding or doing something that may constitute technically a burglary does not give you a hunting license for that person," Langrock said.
Langrock is an expert on self-defense and deadly force. Sixteen years ago he got an acquittal for a Rutland man who fatally shot a teenage burglar armed with a tire iron.
Last year, Langrock's law firm got a not guilty jury verdict for a Shelburne man who fatally shot an unarmed man at a party, claiming he believed the unarmed man had a knife.
Langrock advises using deadly force as an absolute last resort, because even if justified, charges and a trial could follow.
"You don't want to get to that point because the consequences if the jury doesn't agree with you are drastic," Langrock said.
Consequences that could include a conviction for murder.
Jim Melanson doesn't face those consequences because he didn't shoot Eric Edson. But he has a warning for any other burglars considering visiting him or his neighbors: "We all have firearms. We all have loaded pistol and we usually sleep with one."
Justified use of deadly force is a defense often attempted by suspects charged with violent crimes in Vermont but as lawyer Peter Langrock points out it rarely works unless the facts solidly support the claim.
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:27 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:27:22 GMT
Town meeting day didn't bode well for dozens of school budgets across the state. Now the Burlington City Council is looking to cut costs after voters rejected school spending hikes. The council votedMore >>
Town meeting day didn't bode well for dozens of school budgets across the state. Now the Burlington City Council is looking to cut costs after voters rejected school spending hikes.More >>
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:26 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:26:45 GMT
The Vermont Senate has loosened restrictions on the state's medical marijuana dispensaries. The bill passed Tuesday allows an unlimited number of qualified Vermonters to access medical marijuana -- removing theMore >>
The Vermont Senate has loosened restrictions on the state's medical marijuana dispensaries.More >>
Wednesday, March 12 2014 12:26 AM EDT2014-03-12 04:26:03 GMT
A St. George man is behind bars accused of stealing from an elderly South Burlington woman. 43-year-old Craig Dubuque was arrested for the alleged financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult. Police sayMore >>
A St. George man is behind bars accused of stealing from an elderly South Burlington woman.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 11:35 PM EDT2014-03-12 03:35:07 GMT
"You know, people say you might not need it, which is true, but this way you get a choice. I don't have to go out tomorrow," said Lorinda Henry of Milton. Henry says she hit the grocery stores TuesdayMore >>
Parts of Vermont could get up to 24 inches of snow in the coming storm. And VTrans officials are warning drivers they may not be able to keep up with the storm rolling in Wednesday.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 8:02 PM EDT2014-03-12 00:02:07 GMT
"Seems like it was just yesterday. Doesn't seem like it's been two years at all," said Glenda Reandeau of Tupper Lake. Residents of Tupper Lake still have their eyes out for Colin Gillis, a now 20-year-oldMore >>
Colin Gillis of Tupper Lake, N.Y., disappeared two years ago. And authorities are still searching for him. They say the investigation now focuses on tips from the public and from those who were the last to see Gillis.More >>
Tuesday, March 11 2014 6:17 PM EDT2014-03-11 22:17:43 GMT
A Rutland City Police officer is recovering at home after a crash involving his cruiser. Authorities say Officer Adam Lucia was one of two officers responding to an aggravated assault call Monday at TopsMore >>
A Rutland City Police officer is recovering at home after a crash involving his cruiser.More >>